I grew up in a very conservative home and school, so even the discussion of witches and witchcraft isn’t something I encountered much. In a religious sense, I do believe in a supernatural realm, but while church and private school occasionally raised the subject of angels and even demons, witchcraft was never openly or explicitly discussed. I think that’s interesting given the fact that our culture—as evidenced by the television shows mentioned in the blog prompt—contains so many references to witchcraft and the supernatural.
Granted, I don’t believe that the majority of these references provide an accurate depiction of witchcraft as a seriously practiced religion. It’s treated a bit more dramatically or lightly, sometimes with humor, and although many of the supernaturally charged television shows diverge from the broomstick and pointy black hat, you still see a lot of stereotypical images. Upon reflection, many of the cartoons and movies that I watched as a child lightly portrayed the ugly old witch with a warty nose. Even now, some of my favorite books, like the Harry Potter series or the Lord of the Rings trilogy, include witches and wizards. But I didn’t immediately think of them when sitting down to write this entry; that leads me to think that we’re probably so accustomed to such references that they don’t stand out that prominently in our minds.
However, I do agree with the prompt’s suggestion that we don’t fully understand witchcraft and the supernatural. Obviously, that prompts natural curiosity, and our curiosity is undoubtedly heightened even further when something is considered “taboo.” I need only think of the uproar surrounding Harry Potter. I wonder how many people picked up a copy of The Sorcerer’s Stone just to see what the big to-do was all about.
With regard to the term “witch-hunt,” McCarthy and the communist scare of the 1950s that was mentioned in class stands out as a prime example. Drawing on our class discussion of seventeenth-century Salem and that modern-day example, I began thinking about all the characteristics of a witch-hunt. It’s easily fueled by paranoia, anyone and everyone can become suspect, and sometimes all it takes is one person’s word or suggestion to incite fear in people. That made me think of a conversation I recently had with my dad about how some people unfortunately regarded Muslims in
Finally, in our contemporary society, I think you’d hear numerous perspectives on the existence of evil. For many people, religion provides that framework; according to the Christian religion, evil is driven by Satan and is clearly offset by God’s righteousness. But the diversity of belief systems in

7 comments:
Hi Julie,
Great post. Thanks. I think there was some sort of witch hunt after 911. There were Muslims, and people falsely perceived to be Muslim, who were persecuted out of paranoia. Good point. I also like your point about current religious beliefs that are comfortable with some aspects of the invisible world--like angels--but not with witchcraft.
Best,
Dan W.
I agree with what you said about the "witch hunt" effect there was after 9/11, that was really scary to watch and I know that a lot of people were really hurt by it. I think its also really funny how polarizing something like the Harry Potter series is in some communities. I did a paper once on cencorship of those books in particular and was surprised at how strongly some people felt. Many of the people that were against it though had never read the books, it was just the concept of witchcraft alone that made them want to ban Harry. I even have a friend whose dad got really mad when he found out she was reading the series, even though she is 20 years old!
Julie, I love your description of the witch you used to picture as a child. Pointy hat and a warty nose definitely draw memories for me. I too grew up in a fairly conservative home, although my mom was a single mom and our family did not fit the perfect profile of a stable family!
When the 911 attacks occurred and Muslims and those that looked like Muslims were separated and targeted, I was deeply disturbed at some actions taken in the name of preserving safety and security. It is sort of scary to compare that scenario with the Salem witch scenario. Too close for comfort!
Tudor-Stuart Buddy! (Don't fall asleep... and if you do, don't snore! :D) By the way, I drank the Red Bull... bad me. I have no self-control; I'd make a terrible Puritan.
I'm so glad you're blog's finally up and running! I've been wanting to leave you posts.
Before I actually respond to your post, I must say I LOVE the picture at the top of your blog! Did you ever read the *Dear America* series as a girl? They're "diaries" written by girls from various historical periods in American History. I was an avid fan back in the day. Anyway, a few years ago they released a new one on the Salem Witch Trials, which of course I had to buy... and the picture on your blog is the one on the cover! Yay!!!
It was interesting to read your thoughts on witchcraft and the supernatural. You're right: It's something that we don't fully understand, or in some cases don't fully believe in. However, I think that's also part of what draws many to it. As much as people fear what they don't understand, that's also usually what they tend to find most intriguing.
Julie,
I was raised in a really conservative town also, so I definitely relate to growing up in a town where witchcraft isn't mentioned often. Also, I wanted to mention that I agree that curiosity has a lot to do with witchcraft and the popularity of it. Your example of Harry Potter made me think of that board game (I forget the name of it) where everyone sits in a circle and moves a magnifying glass around the letters for it to spell out a word. Some of my friends had that game, and the only reason we ever wanted to play it was only because we were curious...
Julie,
I liked your idea of the post 9/11 attitude towards Muslims mirroring Salem's behavior to the accused witches.
Also, i understand coming from a conservative family, i have a similiar background. Witchcraft and sorcery was never mentioned in my house, so all of this is new to me as well!
Meredith
Julie,
I agree with what you said about the depiction of witchcraft in our society as sometimes almost humorous. Especially the part about witches with a warty nose.
I can remember a handful of years that I dress up as a witch for halloween and wore the pointy hat and everything!
I also agree with what you said about how evil is something that is built from the framework of religion. Especially today, there are so many different religions that believe evil comes from different things.
Steph
Post a Comment